Civil Reference No. 7 of 2004
TRA conducted a tax audit on Illovo Distillers covering the period from 2013 to November 2014 and issued an additional VAT assessment after finding that the company had wrongly claimed and utilized input VAT. Illovo had initially withdrawn certain input VAT claims in its VAT returns but later sought to reinstate those claims after the statutory period had elapsed. TRA rejected the reinstated claims as time-barred under section 16(5) of the Value Added Tax Act, 1997. The Tax Revenue Appeals Board and the Tax Revenue Appeals Tribunal upheld TRA's decision, prompting the appeal to the Court of Appeal.
Whether the reinstatement of previously withdrawn input VAT constituted a fresh input tax claim.
Whether such reinstated input VAT claims were subject to the six-month limitation period under section 16(5) of the Value Added Tax Act, 1997.
Whether TRA lawfully disallowed the reinstated input VAT claims as time-barred.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and held that reinstating previously withdrawn input VAT amounts to making a new input tax claim, not merely correcting an earlier return. Consequently, the reinstated claim must comply with the six-month limitation period prescribed under section 16(5) of the Value Added Tax Act. Since Illovo sought reinstatement after the statutory period had expired, TRA was correct in rejecting the claim as time-barred.
The decision establishes that the reinstatement of withdrawn input VAT is legally treated as a fresh claim rather than an amendment of an existing claim.
It confirms that the six-month statutory limitation under section 16(5) of the Value Added Tax Act is mandatory and strictly enforced.
The case underscores the importance of taxpayers exercising due diligence before withdrawing input VAT claims, as they cannot later revive those claims outside the statutory period.
The judgment provides authoritative guidance on the interpretation of time limits for input VAT claims and reinforces certainty and finality in VAT administration in Tanzania.
Speak directly with our advocates. We turn precedent into actionable advice for your matter.