+255742850702 Get Counsel →

IBM Tanzania Limited v Commissioner General (TRA) Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2024, [2025] TZCA 1240

Ruling Court of Appeal of Tanzania Limitation of time 2025

Summary of Judgment

IBM Tanzania Limited v Commissioner General (TRA) Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2024, [2025] TZCA 1240

Ruling: 1st & 8th December, 2025 - on Preliminary Objection

Important: This is not a decision on the tax merits. It is a Ruling striking out the appeal on a preliminary objection about time / procedure. The Court never decided whether the VAT assessment was correct.

1. FACTS

The tax dispute - background only:2020: TRA audited IBM Tanzania for years of income 2017 and 2018.TRA issued an adjusted VAT assessment for 2017-2018 demanding TZS 1,747,062,804 in additional VAT + interest.Basis: Variance between sales declared in VAT returns vs sales in the Z-report. TRA said Z-report sales were higher, so VAT returns understated sales. TRA also noted discrepancy on exports declared in Z-report vs export details.

IBM objected. Objection partly allowed on reconciliation of exports. Assessment revised down to TZS 1,425,619,187.00.IBM appealed to Tax Revenue Appeals Board - VAT Appeal No. 62 of 2021 - dismissed.

IBM appealed to Tax Revenue Appeals Tribunal (TRAT) - Tax Appeal No. 49 of 2022 - dismissed on 15/2/2024 for lack of merit.The appeal to the Court of Appeal - the procedural chronology that killed the appeal:15/2/2024: TRAT judgment delivered.29/2/2024: IBM wrote letter to Tribunal requesting copies of proceedings, judgment and decree.11/3/2024: IBM lodged Notice of Appeal - within time.12/3/2024: Notice of Appeal served on TRA.2/5/2024: IBM served the letter requesting documents on TRA - 84 days after the judgment, and about 63 days after writing the letter.20/6/2024: IBM lodged the appeal, relying on a Certificate of Delay which excluded the period 29/2/2024 to 23/4/2024 when IBM said it received notification that documents were ready. IBM filed 5 grounds of appeal on the merits. The Court did not reproduce them because the PO was decided first.

2. ISSUES

The Preliminary Objection raised by TRA was:

Is the appeal incompetent for being time-barred, because IBM relied on a defective certificate of delay which improperly excluded 54 days, after IBM's letter requesting copies was served outside the 30 days mandated under Rule 90(3) of the Tanzania Court of Appeal Rules, 2009 (as amended)?

In substance, two sub-issues:

a) Did the 30-day service requirement exist before the 2024 amendment?TRA: Yes. Rule 90(3) as amended by GN No. 188 of 2024 on 22/3/2024 only codified what case law already required.IBM: No. Before 22/3/2024 there was no such requirement in the Rules. IBM filed the letter in time, and late service did not prejudice TRA because TRA knew of the judgment on 15/2/2024 and got the Notice of Appeal on 12/3/2024. Counsel blamed the tax consultant who previously handled the matter, and asked the Court to invoke the overriding objective principle to overlook it as a mere technicality.

b) Was the Certificate of Delay valid?TRA: No. It wrongly reckoned time to when documents were collected, not when IBM was notified they were ready.IBM: Yes. Rule 90 allows exclusion from date of application to date of delivery, i.e. 23/4/2024.

3. HOLDING

Preliminary Objection sustained. Appeal struck out with costs as time-barred.The Court held:

1. The 30-day rule pre-dated the amendment.

Even before 22/3/2024, it was settled law since the 1990s that the letter requesting documents must be served on the respondent within 30 days of delivery of the impugned decision.

Relied on Principal Secretary, Ministry of Defence and National Service v Devram P. Valambhia [1992] TLR 387 - the 30 days under Rule 83(1) [now Rule 90(1)] to apply for proceedings is co-extensive with the period to send a copy of that letter to the respondent.

Novatus Williams Nkwama v TUGHE [2022] TZCA 40

Wood Menders Company Ltd v Xu Li Jun, Civil Appeal No. 233 of 2020 - "it is thus a settled position... a copy of a letter... must be served on the respondent within thirty days of the date when the impugned decision is delivered."

Also cited Commissioner General TRA v Serengeti Breweries, Civil Appeal No. 153 of 2025 and Irene Malanga v Patrick Christopher O'Dwet [2025] TZCA 161.Therefore IBM was required to serve the letter by 16/3/2024 at the latest. Serving on 2/5/2024 was inordinately late.

2. Late service = loss of benefit of exclusion of time.

Failure to serve within 30 days disentitled IBM from excluding the period taken to prepare the documents. IBM therefore had to lodge the appeal within 60 days from lodging the Notice of Appeal on 11/3/2024. Lodging on 20/6/2024 was out of time.3. Overriding objective cannot cure this.

Failure to serve within time is a fatal irregularity touching on limitation. It cannot be glossed over under the overriding objective principle.Relied on Mondorosi Village Council and Others v Tanzania Breweries Ltd and Others [2018] TZCA 303 - overriding objective cannot be applied blindly against mandatory provisions of law.4. Certificate of Delay - not decided.

The Court expressly declined to deal with the defectiveness of the certificate of delay, saying it was inconsequential once the first point was decided.

4. LEGAL SIGNIFICANCE

1. Codification does not create a new rule - it confirms old case law.

Lawyers cannot argue that the 30-day service rule only started on 22/3/2024 with G.N No. 188 of 2024. The Court treats the amendment as declaratory of the position since Valambhia (1992).

2. Service is as important as filing.

It is not enough to write and lodge the Rule 90 letter within time. You must serve a copy on the respondent within 30 days of judgment. Filing without service = no exclusion of time.

3. Limitation is jurisdictional, not technical.

Late service is not a curable irregularity. The overriding objective principle, s.3A Appellate Jurisdiction Act, cannot save an appeal that is time-barred. The Court will strike it out even if the merits look arguable and even if the other side knew about the appeal through the Notice of Appeal.

4. Blaming counsel / consultant is no excuse.

IBM's attempt to shift blame to the tax consultant who previously handled the matter was rejected in substance - the Court noted counsel had no authority for his proposition.

5. Practical warning for tax appeals and all civil appeals:

Diary two deadlines from judgment date:

(i) file Notice of Appeal,

(ii) file and serve Rule 90 letter within 30 days.

Keep proof of service on the respondent - not just filing stamp.

Do not rely on a Certificate of Delay if service was late - the certificate becomes useless.

If you miss the 30 days, your only safe route is to apply for extension of time before lodging, not to rely on exclusion.For IBM specifically: The TZS 1.425bn VAT assessment as upheld by TRAT now stands, because the appeal on merits was never heard.

Key Holdings

NEXT STEPS

Questions on
this ruling?

Speak directly with our advocates. We turn precedent into actionable advice for your matter.